Calgary Insight

City Hall · November 7, 2026

Former mayor rejects blame as details emerge from Bearspaw feeder main inspection report

The provincial inspection of Calgary's water utility traces missed reforms back a decade, and Opposition leader Naheed Nenshi says the report clears him.

Calgary Skyline from the river
Photo: Mule hollandaise, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Key facts

More details and the first political responses have emerged from the independent municipal inspection of the City of Calgary's Bearspaw South Feeder Main, the water line whose failures in June 2024 and December 2025 led to city-wide water restrictions [1][2].

The inspection was carried out by David Goldie, who was appointed under the Municipal Government Act in March 2026 [2]. Water Canada reports that the final report went to the province in October and that the Government of Alberta released it publicly this week; the Lethbridge Herald describes Goldie as having released the report this week [1][2]. The report contains 20 recommendations on how the utility is managed and overseen [1][2].

Much of the new attention is on a 2015–16 review of the water utility by the consulting firm Raftelis Financial. According to the report, then-mayor Naheed Nenshi and his chief of staff received an advance briefing on the draft-final version, while the full report and most of its recommendations never went to council [1][2]. Five of nine priority recommendations were left out, and those five were nearly identical to reforms later proposed by the 2024 independent review panel on the feeder main [1][2]. The Lethbridge Herald reports that Goldie described the handling of that review as irregular and a missed opportunity [1].

The report also says the utility's capital spending from 2006 to 2024 averaged about 35 per cent below approved budgets, and that spending from 2016 to 2020 was 46 per cent below the national average [1][2]. It puts water lost to leaks at 23 per cent in 2025 and notes that a 2022 corporate realignment spread core utility duties across several City departments [1]. The water, wastewater and stormwater network serves more than 1.8 million people and has an estimated replacement value of $89.6 billion, according to the report [1].

Among the recommendations reported by the Lethbridge Herald are moving the water utility into an arm's-length corporation controlled by the municipality, having council hire a consultant to compare that model with integration into ENMAX and report back by the fourth quarter of 2027, keeping a register of the most critical assets and their risks, and treating water loss as a core performance measure [1]. The report also asks the province to consider whether Alberta law gives enough oversight of critical municipal infrastructure [1].

Nenshi, who now leads the Official Opposition NDP, said, "This report exonerates me in the matter" [1]. He also called the release of the report a distraction and accused the government of pursuing a personal vendetta that has cost taxpayers tens of millions of dollars [1].

Municipal Affairs Minister Dan Williams has said he will give the report careful consideration, and that its release is not an immediate decision on any directives to the City [1][2]. Day-to-day operation of the utility stays with the City while the minister reviews it [1]. The report notes that the City has already set up a Water Utility Oversight Board and named an acting chief operating officer, and says their success will depend on clearer decisions, accountability and reporting [2]. Neither article reported a response from the current mayor or council [1][2].

Each statement is marked with the source it comes from. This story summarises those reports in its own words and adds no opinion.

Calgary water utility: capital spending gaps cited in the inspection report

Per cent below (%)
Below approved budgets, 2006–2024 (average)35
Below national average, 2016–202046

Source: Water Canada

Sources

This story is written from the reporting and official notices below. Read them for the full details.

  1. Report blames governance failures for Calgary water crisis – while Nenshi was in charge Lethbridge Herald, November 7, 2026
  2. Province releases report on Calgary's Bearspaw South Feeder Main Water Canada, November 6, 2026

Topics: Water, City Council, City services, Provincial

← Newer: Physicians now triaging patients at six Alberta emergency rooms after months of delay, premier says
Older: Chinook brings wind warning with gusts up to 100 km/h overnight →

Today's Calgary News on the dashboard

All Calgary News · November 2026