Independent study · Calgary 311 data, October 2024 to September 2026
Who Calgary’s 311 Hears
Calgary’s 311 system closes requests just as quickly in poorer neighbourhoods as in richer ones. But it hears far less from neighbourhoods where many residents don’t speak English. For many problems, like a broken streetlight, a resident’s report is how the City finds out, so communities that report less risk having problems missed.
What the study found
1. Communities where more residents don’t speak English make far fewer infrastructure reports
Communities were split into four equal groups by the share of residents with no knowledge of English (2021 Census), and reports about roads, sidewalks, streetlights, water, sewers, parks and trees were counted per 1,000 residents. Comparing communities first settled in the same era, and then allowing for income, renters, community age and distance from downtown, the gap remains: about 23% fewer reports. It holds outside northeast Calgary, for roads, water and parks separately, in each year studied, and under 14 different models. Between the groups with the most and the fewest non-English speakers, reports are lower in 20 of 21 request types, including streetlights (23% lower), potholes (35%) and sidewalks (40%).
2. Once a request is made, the City closes it equally fast in every group
Each community’s requests were compared with the citywide speed for the same type of request in the same year. Across income and language groups, the share closed within 7 days is within 1.5% of expected, and within 0.6% at 30 days. Response is not the problem; the gap is in who reports.
3. Fewer requests come through the 311 app in lower-income and non-English-speaking areas
The share of requests made through the app is lower in these communities, which matters as the City adds languages to the 311 app.
Lower 311 reporting is not automatically good news: it can mean problems go unreported. That is why the study does not score communities “best” or “worst”.
Ward 5, adjusted for growth
Northeast Calgary has grown faster than the 2021 Census shows, so the study models today’s population for Ward 5’s communities. Adjusted, Ward 5 makes 36.8 infrastructure reports per 1,000 residents a year, the lowest of the 14 wards (all study communities: 66.8), about 8% below similar communities; Taradale is 32% below and Martindale 26% below. 78.3% of its requests close within 7 days, against 75.8% for all study communities.
Twelve recommendations
Most can be piloted within existing budgets.
Measure who 311 hears
- Make “reports per 1,000 residents” an official 311 measure
- Refresh the gap analysis every year
Make reporting easier
- Put 311 where people already are
- Add photo-first reporting
- Accept reports by text or WhatsApp
- Close the loop
Reward and encourage reporting
- Fix-It Points
- Community Care Challenge
- 311 Community Ambassadors
- Bring in young people
Don’t rely on reports alone
- Inspect proactively where reporting is low
- Measure “fixed”, not just “closed”
How it was measured, and its limits
Every non-duplicate 311 request from October 1, 2024 to September 30, 2026 (City of Calgary open data), across 30 common service types; 21 of them count as infrastructure. Residents from the 2021 Census; community characteristics from the City’s Calgary Equity Index, Census households and employment, property assessments and building permits. The like-for-like estimate is a population-weighted regression, with 13 alternative models and a 1,000-draw bootstrap that resamples whole areas.
It shows a pattern, not its cause: fewer reports could partly reflect fewer problems, and the City finds some problems through its own inspections. Language figures are for Census areas, not individual residents. The full method explains every choice.
Read the full study
- The full study: an interactive map, profiles of all 195 communities with 52 indicators each, and video briefs
- Report to the City (8-page PDF)
- Methodology (PDF)
- Community indicators (CSV) and the full study package with source data and code
This study is the kind of work the Data Scientist is built for: a question about Calgary answered from public data, every figure worked out and sourced, with findings, recommendations and its limits stated.
See the Data ScientistAn independent study, not affiliated with The City of Calgary. Data: City of Calgary Open Data, Open Government Licence – City of Calgary. Corrections and questions: hello@calgaryinsight.ca.