Calgary Insight

City Hall · November 5, 2026

Provincial inspection of Bearspaw feeder main finds long-standing weaknesses at the City

An independent inspector's report released Thursday makes 20 recommendations on how Calgary governs, funds and manages risk on major water infrastructure.

Calgary Skyline from the river
Photo: Mule hollandaise, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Key facts

The Government of Alberta on Thursday released an independent inspection report on the City of Calgary's handling of the Bearspaw South Feeder Main, the water pipe that failed on June 5, 2024 and again on Dec. 30, 2025 [1].

The report was written by David Goldie, an independent consultant and corporate director who chaired the Alberta Energy Regulator board from 2020 to 2024. He was appointed inspector in March under the Municipal Government Act and delivered his final report to the province in October [1].

According to the province, the report identifies long-standing, systemic weaknesses in the City's governance, management of infrastructure risk, accountability and delivery of capital projects. It makes 20 recommendations [1].

The inspection reaches back to events as early as 2004, including a 2015-16 financial review of the City's utilities by the firm Raftelis. The report finds that the then mayor, Naheed Nenshi, and his chief of staff were briefed in advance on a draft-final version of that review, but that the full report and most of its recommendations were never presented to council. Five of nine priority recommendations from that review never went to council, and the report says they are nearly identical to recommendations made by the 2024 independent review panel on the feeder main [1].

The report also points to spending patterns. From 2006 to 2024, the City's capital spending averaged about 35% below approved budgets, and from 2016 to 2020 capital spending by the water utility averaged 46% below the national average, according to the province's summary [1].

It says the City's governance did not consistently bring together information on infrastructure, finances and risk, and that risks flagged in earlier reviews were not consistently turned into inspections, funded work or corrective action [1].

The report acknowledges steps the City has taken, including starting a Water Utility Oversight Board and appointing an acting chief operating officer, and says their effectiveness is still to be judged [1].

Municipal Affairs Minister Dan Williams will review the findings and recommendations and decide whether to issue any directives. The province says releasing the report is not itself a decision on further action, and that day-to-day water operations remain the City's responsibility [1]. Williams said, "I will give the report the careful consideration it deserves" [1].

The report comes as Stage 4 water restrictions are in place across Calgary while crews connect the replacement feeder main. On Thursday the City said draining of the existing pipe was beginning [2].

Each statement is marked with the source it comes from. This story summarises those reports in its own words and adds no opinion.

How far spending fell short, per the inspection report

Below benchmark (%)
City capital spending vs approved budgets (2006-2024 avg.)35
Water utility capital spending vs national average (2016-2020 avg.)46

Source: Government of Alberta

Sources

This story is written from the reporting and official notices below. Read them for the full details.

  1. Calgary inspection report released Government of Alberta, November 5, 2026
  2. Water savings off to a great start as Bearspaw South Feeder Main connection work moves ahead City of Calgary Newsroom, November 5, 2026

Topics: City services, Water, Provincial, City Council

← Newer: Province tables bills on campus neutrality, deepfakes and consumer protection
Older: Committee backs $511-million bus lane option for Centre Street as Green Line north stalls →

Today's Calgary News on the dashboard

All Calgary News · November 2026